North British Railway: Guard’s Report book: Thornton – Methil line 1889
The information layout out here is taken from a grubby little Guard’s Report Book. It records the shuttle service on the Thornton to Methil line along the Fife coast on the northern shores of the Firth of Forth in 1889. Measuring 21 x 13 cms it would have been slipped in and out of the guard’s pocket innumerable times. At first glance what it records appears utterly mundane and repetitive. A four times daily return trip (5 on Saturdays, but no Sunday service) with a journey time of only 18 minutes. However on closer examination and with a little historical cross referencing it actually reveals some fascinating social details and railway politics.
The dates covered are 2/4/1889 to 27/5/1889 with entries for each day excluding Sundays. It is the record of guard Robert Leith.
The line was constructed principally for coal traffic but this documents the passenger service.
Background and date significance.
The line was built by Randolph Gordon Erskine Wemyss, the Laird of the local Wemyss Castle [not to be confused with Wymess Bay on the west coast Firth of Clyde] and clan chief. There were rich coal deposits under his lands in the immediate area and several collieries. He wanted the means to get this coal to market and thus needed a railway and docks.
Construction started on the Thornton to Buckhaven section in 1879 and opened 2 years later. The Buckhaven to Methil extension opened on 5/5/1887.
This short independant line was surrounded by North British Railway (NBR) lines resulting in some rivalries and the NBR purchased the line on 11/1/1889, with the Laird having a seat on the NBR board. Thereafter the Laird was not happy with the service the NBR provided for the shipment of his coal, with the grievance that they favoured other producers; particulary regarding access to the Methil docks. Around 1900 he therefore built another line of his own which has become know as The Private Wemyss Railway.
This Guard’s Record is thus from just 3 months after the NBR had taken over “his” original line. Laird Wemyss’ recent involvement with the NBR as a board member is hinted at by the entry for 13/4/1889, a Saturday: “Special to Thornton Junction with General Manager”. This left Methil at 1603, stopped at Wemyss Castle at 1609, presumably to pick up the GM as this was the only stop en route to Thornton (where he presumably boarded a main line train). The train then ran straight back to Methil ready to work the 1659 scheduled train. At this time the GM was John Walker who held this office 1874-1891; when he died in post. He would have had good reason to visit to the Laird as a (possibly disgruntled) NBR Board member.
The guard throughout is Robert Leith. On most occasions the driver is John Pattison, but sometimes John Scott or John Anderson take a turn. Whatever the train team of the day they worked the full day’s timetable which on a Saturday is a long day – over 15 hours plus booking on and off time. [The Scottish National Archive hold the NBR staff records and it may be possible to find out more about these men]
The locomotive is usually number 161 – a Drummond 0-6-0T built at Cowlairs in 1877 and named “Buckhaven”; class J82.This is a design similar to the Stroudley Terriers. On a few days engine number 136 is used; an 0-6-0ST built at Cowlairs in 1872, class J81 . On the 17’th May engine 161 works the first 2 round trips and then 136 the remainder. The change of engine appears to be at Methil.
The usual train consist:
This is recorded in the book as: C x 1, T x 3, Gvan x 1. My guess is that this indicates one Composite (first & third), 3 Third class carriages and a goods/guards van, shuttling back and forth.
Occasionally extra rolling stock are added, e.g:
9/4/1889: the 0820 departure from Thornton has a corpse van added for Wemyss Castle.
10 & 11/4/1889: the first round trip of the day has a fish wagon.
11/4/1889: the 1115 Thornton departure has 2 Horse boxes attached for Wemyss Castle.
11/4/1889: a luggage van is attached at Wemyss Castle for the 1350 departure to Thornton.
18/4/1889 (a Thursday): the 1350 departure from Wemyss Castle has 2 Horse boxes attached for Kings Cross!
23/4/1889: “Lifting wagon fish” at Buckhaven.
24/4/1889 (a Wednesday): Horse Box to 1455 Thornton departure; detached at Wemyss Castle.
27/4/1889: “Lifting fish wagon” to 0712 Methil departure. Then attaching carriage on the return leg at Wemyss Castle (0828).
29/4/1889: “Lifting Horse Box” at Wemyss Castle (0720) en route to Thornton.
29/4/1889: “Lifting Wagon Fish” to 1659 Methil departure.
1/5/1889: “Lifting Wagon Fish” to 1342 Methil departure.
3/5/1889: “Goods van for Methil” attached to 1455 Thorton train.
6/5/1889: Horse Box to Thornton 1750 train.
11/5/1889: “Lifting Wagon Fish” to 0712 Methil departure.
13/5/1889: Corpse Van attached to 1455 Thornton departure for Wemyss Castle.
15/5/1889: Horse Box for Methil to 1115 Thornton train, and returned on 1657 Methil departure
21/5/1889: 1455 Thornton departure “cattle for Buckhaven” ? one cattle truck?
The social and economic prominence of the Laird is demonstrated by the comings and goings to Wemyss Castle. Listed above are the movement of horse boxes, corpse and luggage vans, and the visit of the General Manger of the North British Railway. Two other events are of note. On 6/4/1889, a Saturday, departing Methil at 1000 and stopping at Buckhaven is a “Special to Wemyss Castle with concert party”. The empty carriages then ran back non stop to Methil. Then on Saturday 27/4/1889 there is an extra train with the comment “Special to Thornton with through carriage with Mr Wemyss family – for Kings Cross , London.” [see upper right two images of this page]
Many of the railway lines in this area have long since closed. The Kingdom of Fife Railway Preservation Society is though creating a heritage railway base near the site of the former Thornton to Methil line.
No Sunday Service
Last column – Saturday’s only
Methil 0712 1017 1342 1657 2002
Buckhaven 0715 1020 1345 1700 2005
Wemyss Castle 0720 1025 1350 1705 2010
West Wemyss 0724 1029 1354 1709 2014
Thornton Jn 0730 1035 1400 1715 2020
Thornton Jn 0820 1115 1455 1750 2115
West Wemyss 0824 1119 1459 1754 2119
Wemyss Castle 0828 1123 1503 1758 2123
Buckhaven 0833 1128 1508 1803 2128
Methil 0838 1133 1513 1808 2133